🧮 Analysis tool — free

The Case Against James

Weigh the same evidence twice — against the son the jury wanted, and the neighbour nobody suspected.

Everything at Boscombe Pool was read against James McCarthy. Tick what each item honestly supports, then let the canon show its hand.

Drawn from The Boscombe Valley Mystery (The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, 1891) — read the summary & analysis, or try Who Killed Charles McCarthy?, this story's game. More at the Game Room and the tool bench.